|
Partnership Prenups
Many companies are founded on lots of
optimism and make no plans for the day a partnership splits up.
Who will take control of the company
if a partner dies? What happens when an unhappy partner decides to sell his
shares of stock to competitors? How can the other owners stop the sale? The
answers to all those questions should be found in the same place: the partnership's
"buy-sell" agreement. Having one in place can save businesses lots
of time, money and aggravation.
Bernie Meineke, director of the Small
Business Development Center at Georgia State University (GSU) in Atlanta, cautions
that stinting on legal costs at the launch of a business is a dangerous mistake.
He and three full-time consultants handle some 500 cases a year, helping startups
and existing businesses by providing information, ongoing consulting, and adult
education seminars.
Meineke believes it's essential to get
legal advice, but it doesn't have to cost a lot. If people come in prepared,
a good attorney can help them navigate the murky waters of doing business in
today's fast-paced environment.
What Buy-Sells Do
Whether a company is a simple partnership, a limited liability company (LLC),
or a corporation, a buy-sell agreement is a binding contract among the business
owners that controls the buying and selling of interests in the business. A
good buy-sell agreement will make provision for a withdrawing partner, or the
estate of a deceased partner, and will pay the value of the partner's interest
in the company over time. For example, a life insurance policy owned by the
business can fund a purchase in instances of death, or its cash value can be
used as a down payment for buying out a retiring party.
There are four basic types of buy-sell
agreements:
- Entity Purchase Agreement, in which
the business is obligated to purchase the shares of the deceased or departing
owner.
- Cross-Purchase Agreement, in which
the remaining owners must individually purchase the interest of the departing
owner.
- No-Sell /Buy-Sell Agreement, which
allows existing owners to keep control of the business and allows the departing
owner or heirs to benefit from the business' prosperity.
- Wait and See Purchase Agreement,
which gives the business the ability to decide on whether to employ an Equity
Purchase or Cross Purchase Agreement at the time of a triggering event.
Crafting a buy-sell agreement doesn't
have to cost a lot, says attorney Steven Dubner of Higgins & Dubner in Atlanta;
you may get away for as little as $200-$300. "The way I view it, it's preventative
maintenance," Dubner says. "By getting a buy-sell agreement in place
a client saves potentially thousands or tens of thousands of dollars down the
road in litigation expenses."
Considering the modest costs involved,
why don't more people create buy-sell agreements? Both Dubner and Meineke cite
ignorance as a factor: People simply don't know about such agreements. Another
reason is that there seems to be a psychological reluctance to deal with the
disagreeable aspects of a business. Like prenuptial agreements for marriages,
people don't want to plan for the worst, or even the inevitable -- and especially
not the downsides that can come with success. A third reason: A buy-sell agreement
is not a tangible expense, like a photocopier or computers, and therefore does
not seem warranted.
What Happens Without One
A man we'll call Peter Trapper -- he prefers that he and his company not be
named -- is a New York Web site producer and strategist. In 1997, he and some
friends started a Web company. Eventually they incorporated, using a book as
a guide, but neglected to draft a buy-sell agreement. Like many entrepreneurs,
Trapper worked long hours for little money to grow the business. Eventually,
he had a parting of the ways with the CEO and wanted out. He left the company,
but remained a shareholder.
A year later, the company hit it big,
and now makes almost $10 million dollars a year. With success came the move
to force Trapper to sell his shares for what he calls "a pittance."
A legal battle ensued that lasted more than a year. The parties eventually reached
a settlement, but no one was particularly happy with it.
Says Trapper: "The lesson is that
buy-sell agreements are absolutely crucial and that going into business
without one is just begging for trouble. Situations always change, and the only
time that (the agreement) won't come up is when the business is not successful."
Shootout at the Buy-Sell Corral
Sometimes having a buy-sell agreement can lead to some dramatic outcomes. Attorney
Dubner tells of several shareholders in a corporation who wanted to get rid
of one partner. They took advantage of a "shootout" provision in their
buy-sell agreement to put forth an offer to buy out his shares at an unreasonably
low price.
Under the terms of the agreement, the
lone shareholder could either accept the low buyout offer, or force the other
shareholders to sell their stock back to him at the low-ball price they had
offered.
In the end, the partners were outgunned.
The lone partner got financial help from an outside party and forced the other
shareholders to sell out at the undervalued price. The shootout provision brought
a component of fairness to the table that would not have been there if the buy-sell
had not been in place.
Things to Remember When Drafting
a Good Buy-Sell Agreement
- Owners need to establish the value
of a business to ensure a fair payout to the estate of a deceased partner,
as well as setting an amount that will be affordable for the buyers and the
business. Many buy-sells include a clause that requires revaluing the company
on an annual basis.
- Life, whole life, and disability
insurance policies are often used to fund payments for death, disability,
retirement and the early departure of an owner. It's important to make sure
there's adequate coverage to meet the specific needs of a company. Owners
can also draft payout terms -- such as spreading payments out over a ten-year
period.
- Triggering events will bring the
buy-sell agreement into play, including death, disability, or the retirement
of an owner. Other triggering events to consider adding: divorce, bankruptcy,
creditor's judgment against an owner, conviction of a crime, loss of a professional
license, and a third-party offer to purchase.
- Include a mandatory buy-out of a
departing owner's interest, so a market will exist for the owner's shares.
This also protects the business from having shares sold to undesirable partners
or competitors.
Many available resources can provide
practical guidelines for developing a good business model, including How to
Create a Buy-Sell Agreement & Control the Destiny of Your Small Business
by Anthony Mancuso and Bethany Laurence (Nolo Press, 1999). The book is written
for lay people and includes tax and legal information for small business owners.
However, Dubner and Meineke still believe
people need to finalize agreements with an attorney. "Don't do your own
incorporations," says Dubner. "The costs of incorporating through
a competent attorney are so low, why jeopardize this limited liability protection
by trying to do it yourself?"
|